Leafing through Angus MacKay’s book this evening, combing the pages for something far less interesting, I stumbled across the word Cadenza. Surely not!
The word appears above the last “D. C. Thema” in four tunes - MacCrimmon will never return (PS 57), Hector MacLean’s Warning (PS 182), The Menzies’ Salute (PS 218) and The Marquis of Argyll’s Salute (PS 157) - and twice in The MacLeans’ March (PS 77). That’s on pages 17, 38, 52, 55 (twice) and 62. Turning back to MacKay’s page of Instructions (opposite page 1), there is a list of Italian terms to which I have turned a blind eye for 20 years. Tonight, for the first time, I read this:
Cadenza, imports a pause which gives the opportunity for the introduction of an extempore flourish, according to the taste and fancy of the performer. It has a peculiarly happy effect at the close of a variation, in serving to introduce the thema, or groundwork, Urlar, before Da Capo.
Wow! I wish I’d noticed that before. What a wonderful opportunity to make a mark and do something exciting - an unexpected burst of happiness. Angus MacKay, you are a hero!
Back to my task: preparing a dictionary of Gaelic Terms. This is mostly tedious, compiling source spellings, but going through the material closely yields some important discoveries. Last week, I spotted this:
Not exactly a discovery, but despite the fact I regularly consult Roderick Cannon’s edition of Joseph MacDonald’s treatise, this line on folio 25r (and Roderick’s paragraph on it, p. 107) had failed to register. I completely omitted fridh from my recent discussion of words to use when describing cadences. Oops!
For frith, Dwelly gives: “Small, little, trilling”. The plural would be frithean. Colm Ò Baoill suggested that it could be a different word: frìde (plural frìdean). For this, Dwelly’s meanings include “Small pimple” and “Gnome, pigmy, elf”. Joseph used the word “Introduction” for anything from a single grace to a 4-note run, so perhaps the word’s meaning in piping was similar to “grace” and “grace notes”.











My gawd, that is such an interesting find! Like the Purloined Letter, hidden by its very presence…
This opens up such interesting discussions: how long is the Cadenza? is it a flourish, or an improvisation? could that be what some of the insane higher-numbered cuttings in Joseph MacDonald be used for?
I fear absolutely nobody will do anything with this - it’s such a foreign concept and idea to piping! But it once again suggests an environment of fluidity, creativity and musicality on the part of the performer that simply does not exist today.
Wow!
“Here’s a foundation, now here’s a bit of extra room to maneuver”. Lovely. What a grand listening event that would be!
I wonder if other tunes have written-out phrases at this point that we might view as “artificially fixed” examples of cadenzas? That might be useful in giving us examples of the kind of thing that might have been expected here.
David Glen sometimes put an “e cadence” at the beginning of taorludh and crunludh variations. Is this what we’re talking about here?
Malcolm MacPherson typically played this cadenza when he had concluded a selection - say, the end of a urlar.
Listen here